Snohomish Times News
Home | Business News | County News | Entertainment | Local News | Photo Gallery | Prep Sports | Roads Traffic News | Snohomish News Archive | STSPN.COM

Legislature looking to quietly adopt a last-minute carbon tax

Freds Rivertown Alehouse
Published:2020-03-10 State
Legislature looking to quietly adopt a last-minute carbon tax    Print Snohomish Times    
Legislature looking to quietly adopt a last-minute carbon tax

The voters have twice rejected carbon taxes and the legislature has consistently refused to adopt a carbon tax or cap-and-trade system. Despite that, a last-minute carbon tax/cap-and-trade bill that skipped the policy committee hearing process is being pushed by some legislators.

HB 2957 would give complete authority to the Department of Ecology to create a carbon tax or cap-and-trade system. The legislature would not have to approve the system and would only require an “update” on the rules in January of next year.
Department of Ecology staff could create rules that covered companies that emit as few as 25,000 metric tons of CO2. In Washington state, that would include food producers like El Oro Cattle Feeders in Moses Lake and Lamb Weston in Quincy. It could include timber mills like SDS Lumber in Bingen and Vaagen Brothers in Colville. It would include semiconductor manufacturers and solar panel manufacturers.
It would also include companies that manufacture aluminum and concrete. Such manufacturers are known as “energy intensive, trade exposed” industries because they would be hit hard by energy taxes and find it difficult to absorb those costs because they face overseas competition. In the Northeast United States, where they have a cap-and-trade system, manufacturing jobs have declined even as they have increased in the rest of the United States. Closing manufacturing plants in the U.S. actually increases CO2 emissions because the plants move to jurisdictions with lower costs and the products are imported, increasing emissions. This is called “leakage.” The bill attempts to address this concern, saying Ecology can, “give special consideration to energy-intensive and trade-exposed facilities only to the extent necessary in order to address leakage.”
This, however, is a false hope. It is impossible for agency staff to know what rules to adopt that, “only to the extent necessary,” reduce CO2 emissions while preventing manufacturing plants from closing. Plant managers struggle with the question of competition and pricing every day. It is absurd to think Ecology staff can know what plant managers do not. Worse, if Ecology staff get it wrong, they face no consequences. They aren’t fired or reprimanded. Plant managers and workers, however, lose their jobs.
The rules end up offering very strange incentives. When the rules were first proposed in 2015, we asked if shutting down manufacturing would count toward reducing CO2 emissions. A company could then sell credits for those reductions. Ecology staff replied, “they would get credit.” In other words, under the existing proposed rules, the state would actually pay manufacturers to shut down their plants, taking their jobs and CO2 emissions elsewhere. This would be counted as an emissions reduction, even if it increased global CO2 emissions.
Finally, even as the low-carbon fuel standard (LCFS) bill appears dead this session, HB 2957 would give Ecology the authority to design and implement their own version of an LCFS.
It is unclear what will happen with the bill, but given the scope of the potential impact, it deserves more attention than it has received.

Director, Center for the Environment 963-3409

Published: Thursday, June 04, 2020
Applicants Sought For Affordable Housing Projects Applicants Sought For Affordable Housing Projects
Applications for an estimated $1.5 million in federal funds and local funds to develop affordable rental housing and shelter projects will be accepted through July 27, 2020

Published: Thursday, June 04, 2020
Ferry schedules to remain in place Ferry schedules to remain in place
Until further notice, all state ferries will operate on their current reduced schedules

Published: Wednesday, June 03, 2020
WIAA unequivocally condemns racism WIAA unequivocally condemns racism
The WIAA unequivocally condemns racism, hate and all actions motivated by social injustice.

Published: Tuesday, June 02, 2020
Small Business Grants Small Business Grants
WA Department of Commerce Awards Snohomish County Small Business Grants

Published: Tuesday, June 02, 2020
Prison Lockdown During Protests Prison Lockdown During Protests
Federal Prisons Under National Lockdown as Protests Continue After the Death of George

Traffic Conditions Published: 2020-06-01
Fire Fighter Dies
Published: 2020-05-21
Master Gardeners Offer Free Vegetable Gardening Online Classes
Published: 2020-05-20
Community Transit Seeks Input
Published: 2020-05-19
Shop Safe Snohomish
Published: 2020-05-18
Published: 2020-05-18
Community Transit to Restore Fare Collection
Published: 2020-05-17
Small Business Relief

Rairdons Monroe Dodge

Snohomish Sports Network


Live Police Scanner

Snohomish County Sheriff, City of Snohomish,
Lynnwood, Mill Creek, Everett - Police & EMS/Fire


The Worldwide Media Guide